Why conflicting pet behaviour advice can leave owners stuck, and how to find a clearer starting point.
When an animal’s behaviour starts to worry us, looking for advice is often the first thing people do. The difficulty is that advice now comes from search results, online forums, social media groups, well-meaning friends or family, videos, podcasts, books and product recommendations. Some of it may be thoughtful. Some may be outdated, oversimplified, or poorly matched to the animal in front of you.
Yet much of the advice can still sound convincing: walk your dog more, walk them less, change the harness, try a calming product, ignore the behaviour, never ignore the behaviour, give more enrichment, reduce stimulation.
Before long, the issue is no longer only the behaviour. It is deciding which advice to trust!
In psychology, this is often discussed through the Paradox of Choice. Choice can help people feel more in control, but the evidence is more nuanced than the popular phrase sometimes suggests. Research on choice overload indicates that having more options is not automatically harmful. Rather that it becomes more difficult when the options conflict, the decision feels important, and the person is unsure how to compare what is in front of them (Scheibehenne et al., 2010; Chernev et al., 2015).
This is relevant to pet owners because a family may be trying to work out whether their dog needs more exercise or fewer busy walks. A cat owner may be wondering whether hiding is “normal” behaviour or a sign their cat is not coping. Someone with a puppy who mouths may be told to ignore it, redirect it, yelp, walk away, give their pup a chew, or “be firmer”. The advice may all be aimed at the same problem, yet it gives the owner very different starting points and can lead to very different outcomes.
In behaviour work, focus is on identifying what is maintaining the behaviour of concern, then change the conditions that keep setting it up. For example, a dog who barks on lead may be frightened, frustrated, in pain, over-aroused, or trying to create distance. A cat who hides when visitors arrive may need lower social pressure, safer retreat options, or a slower introduction to people entering the home. Two animals can show similar behaviour for very different reasons, so generic advice can easily send people in the wrong direction.
There is also a learning cost for our pets. If the response to barking, lunging, hiding, toileting, or handling changes from day to day, or from one handler to another, your pet has less reliable information about what is safe, what works, and what to expect next. The household may be trying hard, but the learning picture becomes harder for the animal to read. This is where problem behaviours can escalate.
If you feel stuck, start with three questions.
Is everyone safe? What is my animal practising every day? What is one small change I can repeat consistently?
The answer may be a barrier, a quieter walking route, a predictable chill-out space, or consent testing so you can read your animal’s responses more accurately before continuing to stroke them. Choose one change you can repeat, then watch what happens. Trying five things at once can feel productive, but it often creates more uncertainty.
If your pet’s behaviour is getting intense, escalating, risky, or affecting daily life, it is critical to seek genuine, properly assessed support. In the UK, animal trainers, training instructors and behaviourists are not regulated by government, which means anyone can use those titles regardless of training or experience. The Animal Behaviour and Training Council provides a Practitioner Directory to help owners find assessed practitioners by species, county, role and organisation.
To understand more, check out my episode, The Paradox of Choice, below, and explore the full Science of Connection playlist here.
Further Reading
- Chernev, A., Böckenholt, U. and Goodman, J. (2015) Choice overload: A conceptual review and meta-analysis. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 25(2), 333–358. doi: 10.1016/j.jcps.2014.08.002
- Iyengar, S.S. and Lepper, M.R. (2000) When choice is demotivating: Can one desire too much of a good thing? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79(6), 995–1006. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.79.6.995
- Scheibehenne, B., Greifeneder, R. and Todd, P.M. (2010) Can there ever be too many options? A meta-analytic review of choice overload. Journal of Consumer Research, 37(3), 409–425. doi: 10.1086/651235
Learn more about our classes
Get Hanne's book, clothing and more
Hanne has a number of publications including her book Playing With Your Dog to help owners work out the games that are best suited for their pet to play throughout his life, from puppyhood to old age, available from Amazon. Check out Hanne's range of contemporary casuals The Collection – for pet lovers made from recyclable, organic materials that are sustainably sourced.
