What Motivates Your Dog? Using Rewards More Effectively in Training

Home » Latest news » What Motivates Your Dog? Using Rewards More Effectively in Training

Training can be such an enjoyable part of living with a dog, and depending on the methods used, it can deepen the dog-owner bond. However, learning depends on more than presenting a cue and offering a reward. Dogs are more likely to engage when the task is clear, achievable and followed by an outcome they value. As a behaviour becomes predictable, a verbal, visual or tactile cue can be introduced. In this article, I look at how motivation influences learning, why the value of a reward can change, and how we can use reinforcement more thoughtfully during dog training.

How Motivation Influences Dog Training

Motivation describes the processes that influence whether, how strongly and for how long an individual engages in a behaviour. In training, we infer motivation from what a dog chooses to approach, repeat or work to access. Because the value of an outcome can change with the individual, their current state and the setting, effective training involves observing and adjusting rather than assuming one reward will always work (Bremhorst et al., 2018). This has several practical implications for how dogs engage with training, how efficiently they learn and how likely they are to repeat a behaviour.

1. Focus and Engagement: When the task is clear and the outcome is reinforcing, dogs are more likely to remain engaged and repeat the behaviour. Their ability or willingness to participate may still vary with the environment, emotional state, fatigue, satiety, physical comfort and competing opportunities.

Keep sessions brief enough for your dog to remain comfortable and engaged. Two or three minutes may suit many exercises; however, there is no universal training-session length. Pause while your dog is still participating readily, and use their behaviour to guide the duration and difficulty of the session.

2. More Efficient Learning: When the consequence is genuinely reinforcing, the criteria are achievable, and the timing is clear, the dog is more likely to repeat the behaviour. This can make training more efficient, although the rate of learning will vary between dogs, behaviours and environments.

3. Strengthening Desired Behaviour: Positive reinforcement occurs when a consequence follows a behaviour and increases the future likelihood of that behaviour. Food, play, praise, touch, sniffing, chasing, digging or access to another activity can all function as reinforcers, but only when the individual dog values them in that setting.

Ways to Boost Motivation in Dog Training

1. Find Out What Your Dog Values: Offer a small range of safe and suitable options, then observe what your dog chooses or is willing to work to access. Preferences may change with the environment, previous access, hunger, arousal, health and competing opportunities. Preference testing can identify potential reinforcers, while the effect on the dog’s future behaviour tells us whether something is functioning as a reinforcer (Lazaro et al., 2023). The video below demonstrates a simple food preference test. It shows how you can compare the foods offered, while remembering that the result reflects the dog’s preference under those particular conditions.

2. Use Positive Reinforcement Precisely: Mark the behaviour you want, then provide a consequence the dog values. The marker, such as “yes” or the click of a clicker, identifies the relevant moment, while the reinforcer increases the likelihood of that behaviour occurring again.

When a behaviour is new, reinforce successful repetitions often enough for the dog to identify which response is producing the outcome. As the behaviour becomes fluent, the type, amount and timing of reinforcement can vary, while the behaviour should continue to produce worthwhile outcomes. This maintains a healthy ‘bank account’ for behaviours such as recall, settling and leaving items.

3. Make Training Clear and Engaging: Games and interactive activities can help maintain attention and participation, provided the dog remains comfortable and able to disengage. In clicker training, the click marks the target behaviour and is followed by a reinforcer. This can clarify the relationship between the behaviour and its consequence, while supporting precise timing.

4. Match the Reward to the Task: A reward that works well in the kitchen may be unable to compete with smells, movement or social activity outdoors. Think of your dog’s rewards as £5, £20 and £50 equivalents, then match them to the difficulty of the task and the environment.

Varying food rewards may help some dogs maintain motivation over longer sessions, but dogs differ in whether they prefer variety or a consistent favourite (Bremhorst et al., 2018). Varying reward type is also different from withholding reinforcement unpredictably. When teaching a new behaviour, reinforce successful repetitions consistently. Once the behaviour is fluent, the frequency and form of reinforcement can be changed gradually, while ensuring the behaviour continues to pay off.

5. Break Behaviour Into Achievable Steps: Some behaviours are made up of a chain of smaller actions. Retrieving, for example, may involve orienting towards an object, moving towards it, picking it up, holding it, turning back, carrying it and delivering it to the handler. Depending on the dog’s starting point, these parts can be trained separately, or the chain can be built backwards, beginning with delivering the object into the handler’s hand at close range. Reinforce each achievable step, add the verbal cue once the behaviour is predictable, and change one criterion at a time. If progress stalls, review the environment, the current criterion and whether the reinforcer is effective in that setting. Making the next step easier often gives the dog the information they need to continue.

Reinforcing each achievable step keeps the task manageable and helps the dog progress towards the complete behaviour.

A final word…

Motivation is not a fixed characteristic, and a reward does not have a permanent value. Both can change with the individual, their current state and the setting. By keeping criteria achievable, using reinforcement precisely and regularly reassessing what the dog values, we can make training clearer, more humane and more effective.

Because dogs differ, identifying effective reinforcers requires observation and periodic reassessment. Notice what your dog chooses, what they are willing to work for and how this changes across familiar environments and varying levels of distraction. Clear criteria, thoughtful reinforcement and attention to the dog’s emotional and physical state help support learning, confidence and welfare.

Now go and have some fun training with your dog.

References

• Bremhorst, A., Bütler, S., Würbel, H., & Riemer, S. (2018). Incentive motivation in pet dogs: Preference for constant versus varied food rewards. Scientific Reports, 8, 9756. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-28079-5
• Lazaro, X. A., Winter, J. M., Fernand, J. K., Cox, D. J., & Dorey, N. R. (2023). Efficacy of edible and leisure reinforcers with domestic dogs. Animals, 13(19), 3073. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani13193073